Marietta yet again (was: Dark Magic)

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 176704

 "zeldaricdeau" <zeldaricdeau at ...> wrote:

> Should we assume it's ok because she
> [Marietta] deserved it? 

YES!

> Where do we draw the line? 

My friend in the real world a line is never drawn between good and
evil, rather a gray blob is drawn. As for Marietta, she is lucky, very
lucky indeed to still have her skin for pimples to form on. In a real
war a traitor like that would have one hell of a lot more to fear from
her companions than pimples!

I'm curious, when members of this and other Potter groups try to paint
Harry or Hermione's (but for some reason never Ron or Snape's) actions
in a sinister light are they just trying to be provocative or do they
sincerely believe that JKR should embrace Saturday morning cartoon
ethics? I'd really like to know.

 Eggplant