No: HPFGUIDX 177010 > Random 832 wrote: >> it's as if saying "You didn't make a longer list, so >> you're not _allowed_ to say that there's thousands of students" > > Potioncat: > As Bart said, canon is contradictory on the numbers. Random832: That would be true, if there canon stating "40 students in Harry's year". There simply is not.