What's in the Box?

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 177011


> 
> Random832:
> That would be true, if there canon stating "40 students in Harry's 
> year". There simply is not.


Potioncat:
First year flying lesson. Gryffindor and Slytherin combined class. 
We're told there are 20 brooms.

Most of the descriptions of hall ways and games make it seem like a lot 
of students---much more than 40 per year. Yet there are as many 
descriptions that fit with the smaller number. So even when list 
members call for canon at 20 paces, neither side wins.

Some of us, however, argue for the pure fun of it. ;-)