Do we really get our closer?

[James Casey]

No: HPFGUIDX 177051

I have been a fan since the first book. I have watched the stories
develop from book to book. I have hung on every word I read! Now I
need to vent and I chose this forum to do so in. This is, after all,
a place for and of opinion. That being said... I will just chose a
place and go from there. There may not be any noticable order and may
bounce from topic to topic.

Love the books. Hate the movies. In the books we are lead to another
world. One of witches and wizards that has little bearing on our own.
It makes you feel like a child again. Your in a dream world of
imagination and magic. In the movie you feel like your just down the
road somewhere. The wizarding world is not unlike the omish.

In the book Hagrid is half the size of Grawp who is twenty feet.
Hagrid is ten feet tall in the book but no bigger than Shaq in the
movie?

I will not even go into all the parts you never get in the movies. I
only hope all who just watch the movies will one day learne the
enjoyment of the books.

Now to the Deathly Hollows. How could you not see Harry being a
Horcrux after the flash back of that night as it is seen in Godric's
Hollow? With all of the "can't live while the other survives" talk in
the book you had to realize.

I love what Harry sees in the pensive! That was awesome. No other way
to say it. You look back at Snape and see his character differently.
Then when Harry tells Albus he was named after two headmasters and
Snape was the bravest man he ever knew! Wow!

How did Sirius turn into a dog in Azkaban? Wouldn't he need a wand
like Pettigrew did? Maybe not...

How can you not fall in love with Kreacher? At the end when he is
shouting fight! Heck Yeah!

Why is Draco not in Azkaban? He never had a moment like his mother
did where he redeems himself and does good.

Who is the new headmaster? We can only assume it is McGonagall, right?

The battle of Hogwarts is massive! Only fifty four good witches and
wizards die.

Is King's Cross heaven?

There was too much time wasted while they were on the run.

Rita Skeeter is as annoying as Dolores Umbridge. Neither should have
been brought back. Umbridge should have been killed by the centaurs.
They are feared after all and all they did to her is beat her up a
little?

Ron Weasley... He is useless. And JK realized this while writting
this book. You can tell. When he leaves them JK and all of use
realise that there is nothing missing. He doesn't hurt them, other
than feelings, when he leaves. He had made no contributions in the
book, this or any other. And we know she sees this because upon his
return he is a totally different character. She makes a point of
stating it. He is decisive and helpfull. A complete change in his
character.

I have loads more to say and would love to discuss any and all things
Potter with any of you. You can chat on here, though I am new to
this, or e-mail. Thanks for the read and hope you do respond I would
like to hear your opinion.

James Casey