Why did Voldemort die though he had Harry's blood?
allthecoolnamesgone
allthecoolnamesgone at yahoo.co.uk
Sat Sep 15 14:37:29 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 177077
>
> We all know that Harry did not die because his blood was running in
> Voldemort. That kept them connected. But then, when voldemort died,
> he still had Harry's blood. So, the thing which connected them was
> still there. So, how could he die?
>
> nimisha
>
Was it the Blood connection that kept Harry from dying? I'm not sure
of that.
The connection between Voldemort and Harry gets a little confusing as
there are multiple strands to it. Initially they were connected by
nothing. Then after Godric's Hollow Harry received protection from
his mother's 'Blood sacrifice' but became a host to a 'bit' of
Voldemorts soul. Voldemort was 'disembodied but did not die because
his Horcruxes kept him 'anchored' to life.
When Voldemort recreated his body he used Harry's blood. This then
created a second strand of connnection betweem them, which protected
Voldemort from the immediate effect of the blood protection, ie. he
could now touch Harry without damage.
The destruction of the Horcruxes removed Voldemorts immortality.
Dumbledore destroying the ring, Harry destroyed the diary, Rom and
Hermione the Cup, the fiendfyre the Diadem, Neville the snake.
Voldemort destroyed the bit in Harry but not Harry himself because
the Elder wand would not kill its true master. The flaw in that
argument though is that Dumbledore did not intend V to get the Elder
wand nor could he forsee that the mastery of it would come to Harry.
All along though Dumbledore was adamant that Harry must 'die' at V's
hand.
So, was Harry's 'tie' to life the blood connection or possession
of 'The Hallows'. I am still not sure, but tend to agree that if
Harry's tie to life was solely the blood then it should work both
ways and have tied V as well. In Kings Cross, Dumbledore says that
Harry has a choice to return to life or 'catch a train'. He only
seems to have that choice because he is 'whole'. Voldemort's soul has
arrive there barely alive and apparently incapable of much at all,
except to lie under a bench and whimper. Presumably all the other
bits of his soul arrive in the afterlife in the same condition.
Therefore after death he is incapable of exercising a choice to
return (even though a 'tie to life' exists) as he is too mutilated to
do so.
I enjoyed DH because it brought the series to it conclusion and
initially answered my questions. But now, nearly two months later I
have to admit a lot of lingering dissatisfaction with issues like
this one that seem to have been a bit 'fudged'. So the short answer
to your question is 'I don't know' and now I'm not sure JKR does
either!
allthecoolnamesgone
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive