Why did Voldemort die though he had Harry's blood?

Steve bboyminn at yahoo.com
Sun Sep 16 06:36:16 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 177089

---"allthecoolnamesgone"  wrote:
>
> > nimisha:
> > 
> > We all know that Harry did not die because his 
> > blood was running in Voldemort. That kept them 
> > connected. But then, when voldemort died,he still
> > had Harry's blood. So, the thing which connected
> > them was still there. So, how could he die?
> > 
> > nimisha
> >

> allthecoolnamesgone: 
>
> Was it the Blood connection that kept Harry from 
> dying? I'm not sure of that.
> 

bboyminn:

On this secondary aspect, I agree, what saved harry is
not as simple as one thing. It is a complex intermix of
a wide range of things.


> allthecoolnamesgone: 
>
> ...
> 
> ... I ...tend to agree that if Harry's tie to life 
> was solely the blood then it should work both ways
> and have tied V as well. In Kings Cross, Dumbledore
> says that Harry has a choice to return to life or 
> 'catch a train'. He only seems to have that choice 
> because he is 'whole'. Voldemort's soul has arrive
> there barely alive ....

bboyminn:

I agree, but to an extremely limited extent. Let me
ask you this, if /I/ create a Horcrux, are /you/ 
protected by it? I think not. Voldemort having Harry
blood is similar in its action to a Horcrux. As long
as Harry's protective blood remains on earth, Harry
is protected from death, or at least, is given a choice.

How does or how can that possible protect Voldemort?
It can't. For Voldemort to be protected, someone
somewhere would have to have a few drops of Voldemort's
'protected' blood in them. But first and foremost,
Voldemort's blood doesn't carry the same protection
that is offerred by Lily's sacrifice. Second, even
if Voldemort's blood was magically protected in the
same way as Harry's, no one else is holding Voldemort's
blood in their living body. So, no protection for 
Voldemort. 

However, I do acknowledge a limited degree of 
protection. Notice the both Harry /and/ Voldemort are
found in the limbo of the King's Cross scene. I 
suspect, /IF/ Voldemort had no more Horcruxes
protecting him, Harry could have simply chosen to 
/go on/, and Voldemort would have had no choice
but to follow. Under other circumstances, it would
have been a way to kill Voldemort. However, Voldemort
still has one Horcrux left, so Harry job is unfinished.
He has to go back in order to assure Voldemort's 
final demise. 

So, as I said, to an extremely limited extent, Harry
blood is protecting Voldemort. When Harry choses to
come back, he is also making that same choice for
Voldemort. 

In short, Voldemort having Harry's blood protects
Harry, but no one else. Just like my having a
Horcrux doesn't protect you.

Steve/bboyminn





More information about the HPforGrownups archive