What is in the box - Prank and SHIPS ( surprising and otherwise) WAS Surp

marion11111 marion11111 at yahoo.com
Sun Sep 16 23:28:10 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 177103


> Alla said:
> 
> Since I started liking Snape/Sirius more, I had to take another look 
> at Sirius/ Remus, so the most convincing to me were their dynamics 
> in OOP. How Remus was always there, they gave presents together, etc.
> 
> And of course "embraced like brothers" can be interpreted not only 
> that way.
> 

marion11111;
I haven't been on this list very long and am hopeless in searching archives, but I always 
thought that SHIP (Sirius/Lupin) started with the PoA movie.  The exact quote you 
mentioned from the book was played out in the movie in a way that made people read 
more into it.  That was a clumsy sentence, but you get my drift.  

And maybe the SHIP started before that, but that's been my understanding. If anyone 
who's been following the fansites long enough can say yes or no on this, that would be 
interesting to know.

I laughed out loud in the OotP movie when Sirius is talking to Harry in a doorway and 
Lupin just appears behind him like the dutiful wife.  Now, we know from the books that 
Lupin is at Grimmauld Place because he's unemployed and has nowhere else to live, but it 
just *looked* funny.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive