CHAPDISC: DH27, The Final Hiding Place
potioncat
willsonkmom at msn.com
Sat Aug 23 11:36:15 UTC 2008
No: HPFGUIDX 184154
> Carol responds:
snip
(I thought that Travers, Imperiused by Harry in
> the Gringotts break-in, was in the battle, but I can't find him now.
> Apparently, he was either still at Gringotts, recovering from
Harry's
> Imperius Curse, or he was killed by Voldemort after the break-in.)
Potioncat:
I was curious about Travers once before, and re-read the Gringotts
chapter very carefully. The last we see him, he's hiding in a niche
in the tunnel. Well, with all the blasting out of the passageways to
make room for a dragon, I doubt Travers survived.
I wonder what happened to Griphook too. The Goblin (not Griphook) who
reports to LV dies. Did he report voluntarily, was summoned, or
brought in by the DEs? Afterwards, what did the surviving Goblins do
to Griphook, do you think?
I will feel really stupid if Griphook was fighting at Hogwarts.
Carol:
However,
> the only names given are those that Harry recognizes, and at least
> some of the DEs kept their hoods on, so he couldn't tell who they
were.
Potioncat:
I wonder why JKR didn't identify the DEs who died because of LV's
tantrum? Wouldn't that give it a bigger emotional punch? I pictured
LV as sort of waving his wand wildly while yelling the AK curse--so
that the killing was random. But others seem to think he had to aim
at one specific person at a time and cast the curse. Still sort of
random, but with aiming involved.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive