Draco's Hand of Glory / Secondary characters' story
dumbledore11214
dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Thu Jul 31 01:02:09 UTC 2008
No: HPFGUIDX 183917
> Montavilla47:
> Here's a few more things we know about Draco's family:
>
>> <HUGE SNIP, go UPTHREAD to read what we know>
> All in all, quite a bit.
>
Alla:
In general I would agree that we know about Draco's family more than
we know about Hermione's. Even though just as Linda I do not recall
the names of Draco's grandparents being in the book either, or how
old Lucius is I do not recall that being in the book too.
I mean, they are wizards, makes sense to me that they would be
featuring in story more than muggles' family.
But that to me does not make Draco a major character by all means,
neither to me does it mean **him** having coming of age story.
I see Draco as being an interesting piece, no more in Harry's coming
of age story. That has nothing to do with me disliking this character
by the way. I feel that way about stories of the characters I like
too.
But suggestion that Betsy made that Draco's story had been taken away
or substantial chunk of it being taken away by Draco ending up with
Hand's of glory, well amuses me. My opinion of course. But as far as
I am concerned, there is **no** Draco's story in itself, just as
there is no Sirius' story in itself, or Ron's story in itself ( whom
I adore too by the way) or Hermione's story. IMO they all have
stories only as much as it affects Harry. When it does not affect
Harry, author feels free to drop the stories as she pleases or change
them, or whatever.
We may like or dislike what she does with secondary characters,
goodness knows I would love for Sirius to be something more than
character that was being created only for Harry to experience another
loss of parental figure IMO. But I believe that JKR was primarily
concerned with telling Harry and Voldemort's story and every other
character's story was moving around that.
I mean, it is as if I would say that substantial chunk of Sirius's
story was taken away by killing him, I liked to imagine before I read
OOP that Sirius will survive the war and he would be living with
Harry's family or near it. But this story existed only in my
imagination or in fanfiction. Author never wanted to tell that story,
so how could it be taken away?
And yes, I believe that JKR wanted to tell the story of spoiled
little boy, who is growing up by being touched by events of something
bigger, by events of Harry's story pretty much.
IMO of course.
Alla
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive