Muggles v wizards redux

[kempermentor]

No: HPFGUIDX 183254

> Alla:
> What is the canon for the argument that Hermione lies to her parents 
> not like any other wizarding teenager or any teenager would lie to 
> get out of trouble or to hide their problems?

Kemper now:
I don't have the canon, but doesn't she say/imply that she hasn't told
her parents anything with regards to Cedric and Voldemort returning to
power?  This is information that she consciously does not discuss with
them.  It is a lie of omission.  


> Alla:
> I am not even talking about justifications for what Hermione does. 
> How exactly are they being treated differently? Are we talking of 
> sending them to Australia? Because so far I cannot come up with 
> anything else.
> 
> Yes, I confess I find what Hermione did in DH to be very touching.

Kemper now:
I'm okay with the memory charm on the parents if the parents were in
choice of that decision.  

If my magical child ever did that to me without it being my choice, he
better leave me that... because I will smite him.

Kemper