Working mothers, was Did the Slytherins come back

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 182067

> > >>Pippin:
> > Then may I humbly ask that you apply  said skills and 
> > intelligence to explain how  your theory  accounts for Cho Chang, 
> > Mme Maxime, the Patil sisters, or Fleur Delacour, all of 
> > whom were able to enjoy a good snog without having set their cap 
> > for someone or being  morally deficient?
> 
> Betsy Hp:
> Up until she gets married, Fleur is not considered a good girl.

Alla:

She is not? I never doubted Fleur's moral sufficiency before she is 
married.

But I take it your argument is that canon does not consider her to be 
a good girl, not the reader?

Where? Are you talking about her fights with Molly by any chance? Or 
something else?



BettyHp:
 The 
> Patil sisters, like Lavender, are considered flighty, Cho Chang is 
> painted as completely untrustworthy by Ginny in the final battle of 
> Hogwarts (Ginny's extreme worry about Cho being the one to take 
Harry 
> to the Ravenclaw dorms).  <SNIP>


Alla:

Cho untrustworthy? 
I always read it as sign of Ginny's extreme jealousy and nothing 
more, did not even come to me that it can be read as judgment of Cho, 
but just my opinion.