GoF CH 27-29 Post DH look
dumbledore11214
dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Wed Mar 19 18:36:52 UTC 2008
No: HPFGUIDX 182167
Lea:
<SNIP>
(iii) It is of course part of the whole Harry/Snape dynamic that
they are both wrong about each others' motives. I don't think Snape
actively reads Harry's mind except during Occlumency, just picks up
vibes, or he would know more about Harry's motives. And of course,
he is also probably picking up vibes from the horcrux in Harry's
head, which wouldn't help.
<SNIP>
Alla:
I believe that while Harry was wrong about Snape's loyalties he was
always spot on about Snape hating him. But in any event I think that
by the fact of Snape contributing to destroying Harry's life as it
could have been, Harry by default earned the right to be as wrong
about Snape as he wishes to and still be forgiven. And Snape
attacking him in the beginning increased that belief of mine.
But I want to ask a question, what does picking vibes mean?
You think Snape does not legilimence Harry every time he looks at
him? Is any other way of telepathy or something similar exists in
Potterverse? I do not think it does, am I wrong? Something like
empathy you mean? Picking up emotions?
I do think that Snape legilimences Harry every time he looks at him,
otherwise why stressing that eye contact occurs. IMO of course.
And boy do I hate that ( and yes I hate when Dumbledore does that as
well), but I think that he does not want to let Harry know that he
does that, because I speculate that more in depth legilimency may
cause some sort of feeling to the mind that is being raped ( that is
what to me legilimency is).
So I speculate that Snape can only touch very surface of Harry's mind
without him knowing that he does something and that is how he may
know sometimes what Harry did but not why.
JMO,
Alla
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive