Snape and Dumbledore in GoF

happyjoeysmiley happyjoeysmiley at yahoo.com
Mon Nov 24 04:15:02 UTC 2008


No: HPFGUIDX 184989

2 questions in GoF:

1. Doesn't it seem quite odd that Snape never discussed with DD the
problem of Moody (fake one, of course) searching his office,
especially when he was told that it was DD who gave the orders?

2. Moody has told DD that Snape was the one who told Moody about the
Barty Crouch Sr issue i.e. the night when Harry and Krum find Barty 
Crouch Sr in a strange condition and when the fake Moody arrives there 
saying had Snape told him everything. Seems like Dumbledore has never 
discussed this point with Snape.

The Prince's Tale chapter gave me an impression that both of them
always discussed all significant incidents during their one-on-one
conversations. So, post-DH, these 2 points looked extremely unlikely
to me. Has this been explained somewhere in canon??

PS: Apologies for having inadvertently sent the earlier post even 
before I completed typing it out. I deleted the post but I guess it 
would have triggered the group mail anyway.

~Joey






More information about the HPforGrownups archive