Snape and moral courage WAS: Re: The Houses, Finally

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 184680

> Leah: But, like it or not, ResurrectionStone!Lily is totally onside 
> with the idea of Harry dying- she's so proud of him. She's not 
advising 
> him to ignore Dumbledore and Snape and get the heck out of it. 
There's 
> no suggestion that Snape is ever happy in going along with 
Dumbledore's 
> plans for Harry, whereas Harry's parents and godfather are really 
gung-
> ho about it.  I can imagine Snape finding the whole scene rather 
> disturbing - I certainly did.


Alla:

I did not, although had it been alive Lily I may have.

What is resurrection stone Lily? If she is just the shadow of the 
alive one, wouldn't it mean that it is half of happening in Harry's 
head anyways?

So of course he would imagine his parents and godfather supporting 
him, to give himself extra courage etc?

If this was a full soul of Lily, meaning that she shares all the 
thoughts of the alive one, wouldn't she see that Harry is set on his 
task and to support him is better than to cry?

Potioncat:
<SNIP>

But even Lily, James, and Sirius expect Harry to risk the sacrifice.
It's what they did.

Alla:

See above. It is just a different issue to me from Snape being 
Harry's "protector", that's all.

JMO,

Alla