Choices/Snape as abuser, SKIP if not interested WAS :Re: CHAPTER

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 188580


> Alla:
> But as we decided with Potioncat long time ago, I can allow for possibility of Snape's twins doing it :)

Potioncat:
The twins! Boy, those were the days. It took me a few minutes to remember where they actually came from.

> Alla:
> Seriously though, when I read for the first time that not everybody agrees with it, I was shocked. Not because I dislike Snape so much, but it was just like huh, who else could have done it. Again, it is my opinion, I am just saying that it was hard for me to understand it.
> 

Potioncat:
Me too. I had the same reaction--from a different point of view. It never crossed my mind as I was reading it that the vial didn't fall on its own. So it was a real surprise that there were other perspectives on it. 

My stand reminds that we have many plausible ideas, but we really don't know what happened. We do how Snape reacted--and while I can exlain his emotional state, I can't condone his response.