CHAPDISC: DH, EPILOGUE

wildirishrose01us wildirishrose at fiber.net
Sat Jan 24 02:33:02 UTC 2009


No: HPFGUIDX 185406

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "seanmulligan2000" > 
seanmulligan2000:
> 
>Snape saved Dumbledore's life when Dumbledore's hand was cursed when
> Dumbledore put on the locket.

Marianne:

Please forgive me and tell me if I'm wrong, but huh?????  I thought 
it was Marvolo's ring that cursed Dumbledore's hand?

>Snape tried to save his godson from being a murderer to fulfill 
>Dumbledore's plan resulting in everone on the good side believing he 
>was a traitor and villifying him. 

Marianne:

Again. Huh?  Snape had a godson?  Are you talking about Draco?

I have a OT question.  Sort of OT.  How did the Elder Wand get back 
to Dumbledore?  Draco took it, and I lost track of the wand until LV 
took it back from DD's tomb in DH.  Did Draco drop the wand when he 
fled with Snape, and someone picked up the wand and returned it to 
DD's body?  Have I not read/listened good enough to the book, or is 
the reader left to make their own conclusion.

Marianne

Marianne





More information about the HPforGrownups archive