CHAPDISC: DH36, THE FLAW IN THE PLAN

[montavilla47]

No: HPFGUIDX 185458

> Carol responds:
> It does seem that by the end of the novel, after Voldemort has further
> humiliated her family and killed who knows how many followers in a
> blind rage, that her support for him has ended. All she wants at that
> point is to get to her son. But I doubt that her views on Pure-blood
> supremacy and whatever drew her to Voldemort in the first place has
> changed. She stills loves Lucius, who is not averse to casting
> Unforgiveables to get his way (when he has a wand, that is), and I
> doubt that she would have any scruples about using, say, Crucio or
> Imperio to get her way if she saw the need--though, admittedly, she
> isn't a sadist like Bellatrix who casts Crucios for enjoyment.

Montavilla47:
Sorry, but when did Lucius cast an Unforgivable?  I know we saw
Draco use Crucio on occasion, but I don't remember Lucius 
ever using an Unforgivable curse, even though he's perfectly
happy to do other nasty things.

IOW, I'm not asking in order to make any moral points for Lucius.
I'm only after accuracy.  And if I'm wrong, I apologize for the 
digression.