Snape and Lucius was James and Intent And Snape

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 187079

 
> 
> Marion:
> 
> Interesting, you seem to think that the only 'good people' in the WW are
> Dumbledore supporters. Well, that's your opinion, 

Potioncat:
No it isn't. 

If it sounded that way, it wasn't supposed to. I was responding to several posts. My opinion is that Lucius was very content to be a DE, but he didn't like following LV. He wanted to be in charge and continue his own agenda of ridding the WW of Muggleborns.


Marion:
 (and
> isn't it amazing that during Snape's year as Headmaster, a year where
> actual DE's run riot through Hogwarts, not one student actually got hurt?)

Potioncat:
As much as I like Snape, I don't agree that no one got hurt. Neville is scarred, a first year was hanging in the dungeon and one student was so severely punished that Neville backed off on the resistence.

I also agree that DD wasn't a good headmaster, and I thought that long before DH---but I don't see him as so horrible as you. Just differing opinions, I think.