Wizarding Top Ten Hermione's "guilt"

[Brian]

No: HPFGUIDX 188045


Kemper:
"Canon gives very clear evidence of Hermione's lack of concern in 
attaining consent.
It was an abusive act done out of selfishness. It was a perversion of love.
It was not an act of love."


With respect, that's doesn't make sense.
Sending them away to be safe could be construed as an act of selfishness.
Making it so they won't miss her if she dies?
Just HOW is that selfish?
I'm not debating whether she is right or wrong to do it, IF she does it 
without consent, but it isn't selfish.
And many of you are convicting her of doing it without consent on 
carefully selected character evidence only, much of that from when she 
was TWELVE years old, there isn't even circumstantial evidence against her.
If I'm ever accused of a crime, I hope you lot aren't my jury!

Brian