An Understanding between Harry and Snape

Joey Smiley happyjoeysmiley at yahoo.com
Wed Jul 6 05:01:19 UTC 2011


No: HPFGUIDX 190821

Mike Crudele wrote:
> > How do we know that the silver doe was Lily's patronus? 
> > Was this speculation on our part, on Harry's part, or 
> > is there some canon proof that this was Lily's patronus?
 
Zanooda responded:
> If you count Harry's words as canon proof, then yes :-). He said it during the last confrontation with LV. I don't know why he thought that, but aren't we supposed to believe *everything* Harry said after returning from the limbo :-)? People do acquire some kind of mystical knowledge on the other side, I guess...

Joey:

Ah, you're right! He said that to Voldy, I remember now. Um, but I thought he *deduced* that even while he was going through Snape's memories in the TPT chapter of DH? :-) I don't know but I always read it that way. :-) 






More information about the HPforGrownups archive