Chapter Discussion: Prisoner of Azkaban Ch 18: Moony, Wormtail, Padfoot and Pron

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 190538

Oh, I have an idea. Maybe this would show more clearly how I feel. As I said, in my mind Sirius may have wanted to kill the Snape or he just wanted to play a joke on him. I know which one I believe, but as I said I fully acknowledge the other possibility.

Now lets imagine that somebody who had no idea whatsoever who was in the Shack, but knew how to get there, gave Snape such information, this somebody is completely innocent and we know it, he does not want to harm Snape, just wants to be helpful and he has no idea that there is a werewolf there.

Now raise your hand, if somebody has ANY doubt that Snape would have gone there no matter who gave him that information. Does his responsibility in the matter gets any less just because the party who actually gave him the information may have wanted to harm him?!

I just do not think so.


JMO,

Alla