Did anyone else notice this?

Liz Clark liz.treky at ntlworld.com
Thu Jun 30 20:19:08 UTC 2011


No: HPFGUIDX 190713

> AJM:
> Did anyone else notice that, when the dementors were first 
> mentioned, before Harry actually saw a dementor and understood
> what they actually were, everyone just called them the Azkaban 
> guards.  Once Harry had seen a dementor, everyone called them 
> dementors when referring to them rather than just the Azkaban 
> guards.  <snip>


Taya responds:
I noticed this too. It happens a lot, until JKR reveals what 
something is, everyone calls it whatever Harry thinks it is. 
Once Harry finds out the proper name, everyone calls it that. 
I think it has to do with the fact that if HeRmione called 
them Dementors, Harry would then ask, what's a Dementor? 
And the reveal would be ruined IMO :)





More information about the HPforGrownups archive