My husband had a Snapethought

Amanda editor at mandolabar.yahoo.invalid
Tue Jul 29 19:26:03 UTC 2003


My husband, Jan, is working his way through OoP. He made an 
observation which totally missed me. This is superbly amazing because 
not only am I a L.O.O.N., it's about *Snape,* for God's sake.

I can't imagine nobody else caught it, but I haven't been anywhere 
near keeping up with the main list at all. If any of you who *have* 
been keeping up think I should post it over there, please let me know-
-it may be known and done to death, but it may not. However, I don't 
*think* I've seen it here, so here goes.

Jan has gotten through the pensieve scene. And his basic take is that 
James was your basic BMOC (big man on campus), a jock, like the guy 
that walks around with a football under his arm. Yeah, I got that 
much. But the thing I missed was what he considered the obvious 
parallel to Snape's being taunted--not Harry in the graveyard, but 
the DEs at the World Cup. Down to the same spell, he said, and he's 
likely correct; the Robertsons were held in midair and at one point, 
the Mrs. was flipped upside down.

I had completely missed this, and found it chilling, especially the 
similarity of treatment of the victim. I'm at work now, can't analyze 
much, but I was stunned that I'd totally missed this and wanted to 
get other thoughts. Thoughts?

~Amanda





More information about the the_old_crowd archive