Apparate to Possess
Barry Arrowsmith
arrowsmithbt at kneasy.yahoo.invalid
Wed Feb 16 17:36:52 UTC 2005
>
> As preparation for HBP I've been dusting off my old theory, > that
Kneasy led me into, that Harry was Possessed by LV at > Godric's
Hollow, and some explanation for the 'missing' 24 > hours.
> As part of this I've recently come up with the following idea.
> Voldemort definitely Possessed Harry in the Ministry of >
Magic.
> But what is the mechanism for Possession ?
> Is Possession a more finely focused development of
> Apparation ?
Kneasy:
Possession. At last!
"O frabjous day! Callooh! Callay!"
He chortled in his joy.
But soft. Restrain yourself.
Mask the manic eyes and the foam-flecked lips.
Appear reasonable, considered, judicious.
And besides, Phil has noticed a possible wrinkle, indeed a possible
clue, that may add to our sum of knowledge of that fascinating subject.
>
JKR gives a detailed description of Apparating in GoF, a suspicious
reader might say unusually detailed.
"GoF, Chapter 'The Portkey', page 63 UK"
'You have to pass a test to Apparate ?' Harry asked.
'Oh yes,' said Mr Weasley...'The Department of Magical
Transportation had to fine a couple of people the other day for
Apparating without a licence.
It's not easy, Apparition, and when it's not done properly it
can lead to nasty complications. This pair I'm talking about went
and splinched themselves.'
'Er - splinched ?' said Harry.
'They left half of themselves behind,' said Mr Weasley...
> snip>
When LV left Harry at GH, theory still being dusted, he
splinched himself (and Harry)so that a part of LV remained in Harry,
and part of Harry was in LV.
Hence the mind link, stronger than the scar link, when LV regained
a body at the end of GoF.
>
Kneasy:
It's an interesting possibility.
If it's not a variant of Apparating then at the very least it could be
a similar technique. A projection over a distance of mind and/or
matter.
Splinching is regarded as poorly exercised magic. What happened between
Harry and Voldy at GH was an unintended result, yes - but a result of
the protection that had been emplaced rather than sloppy casting on the
part of his evilness, I think. Mind you, explaining a split personality
in terms of apparating would make a mental division easier to envisage
and accept.
But it's the result that counts. Voldy was split.
(But see below.)
Reading the books, there seem to be a surprising number of magical
devices whose sole purpose is to be aimed at the minds of others. From
Confundus, Legilimancy (type A - with wand), Imperio, Legilimancy (type
B - without wand, Voldy and DD for the use of) and through to
Possession, it resembles a sliding scale of intrusion, with the upper
reaches accessible only to the most powerful of wizards. (I'd rate
Legilimancy type B higher than Imperio because it's performed without
wands and, so far as we know, only the top two rated wizards in the
world are expert.)
We've known from book 1 that Voldy can possess, if riding as a hag is
true possession, though colonisation might be a more accurate word to
use in that instance. But there may be parallels - the scar and it's
associated powers may be Quirrell and Face writ small.
Shamefully, despite all my past whitterings about Voldy invading Harry,
the thought that there's a reciprocal deal, that part of Harry now
resides in Voldy has never occurred to me. Blinkered, you see. Must
open my mind to encompass such wonderful possibilities. What else has
slipped beneath the radar?
Must give this theory some thought. I promise to post something on
this in a day or so.
Phil:
>
Then in OoP, Chapter 'The Only One He Ever Feared', pages 719-720 UK.
The splinching may have been 'repaired' by the *second*
possession in the Ministry of Magic. DD's crooked nose was inches from
Harry's as Harry recovered from the possession, so DD was probably
checking by eye contact whether LV could still be seen in Harry's eyes.
This may explain how DD was able to face Harry back at Hogwarts.
It seems such a minor detail, but could Possession be very accurate
Apparition ?
And has the 'second' posssession undone any Splinching ?
This may mean that Harry is no longer a Parselmouth besides breaking
the mind link.
>
Kneasy:
The possibility that Voldy is once again whole has been the subject of
posts of mine in the past.
Brief resume.
Harry has scar plus powers, a Voldy enclave. It serves some useful
purpose, it warns (non-specifically) when Voldy is stirring, it's
responsible for his parceltongue ability plus other stuff (wish I knew
what).
GoF. Voldy overcomes Lily's protection, he can touch Harry, and it's
from there that we can trace the mind connection between the two. Now
it's no longer non-specific; both of them have clear mind images of
what's going on, or of what Voldy wants Harry to see. It's as if the
protection quarantined the invasive bits and when the protection was
negated the Voldy bits grew more powerful, or at least had a greater
influence over Harry. A foreign body had been encysted, now the cyst
was breaking down, it's contents leaking. There is a danger of a
systemic infection, though it hasn't happened yet. ("But in essence
divided?" And what if the answer had been "No."?) The protection wasn't
just against external dangers but internal ones too. Harry is very
vulnerable.
OoP. Voldy enters Harry. A full possession. He is forced to withdraw.
He *could* have taken his strays with him ("Come to papa").
Unfortunately it happened right at the end of the book and no
opportunity has arisen to test the scar, powers, or mind contact. Damn.
Speculation.
If they have returned to where they belong expect Voldy to be stronger
and Harry not to have any warning when Voldy's up to something. No more
need for Legilimancy.
If they haven't (my bet) Harry is in danger of becoming more like Voldy
as the influence exerted becomes stronger. Legilimancy becomes
immensely more difficult, it may even be too late for it to be
effective; the real danger is already inside Harry.
Now won't that be fun?
More information about the the_old_crowd
archive