[the_old_crowd] Apparate to Possess
susiequsie23
susiequsie23 at cubfanbudwoman.yahoo.invalid
Tue Feb 15 23:53:50 UTC 2005
Phil wrote:
<major snippage>
> Then in OoP, Chapter 'The Only One He Ever Feared', pages 719-720 UK.
> The splinching may have been 'repaired' by the *second* possession
> in the Ministry of Magic. DD's crooked nose was inches from Harry's
> as Harry recovered from the possession, so DD was probably checking
> by eye contact whether LV could still be seen in Harry's eyes.
> This may explain how DD was able to face Harry back at Hogwarts.
> It seems such a minor detail, but could Possession be very accurate
> Apparition ?
> And has the 'second' posssession undone any Splinching ?
> This may mean that Harry is no longer a Parselmouth besides breaking
> the mind link.
SSSusan:
My first post at TOC is going to be a glorified "me, too!," which is pathetic I realize, but I have to say I really like this idea, Phil. It has bugged me to no end that some people seem to think that Harry will have to continue Occlumency in year 6 because nothing has changed, whereas others seem to think there is no reason to believe the mind link is still present, so Occlumency will no longer be necessarry. I've never quite understood why it's been so "clear" to some posters that the MoM Voldy possession somehow undid everything, made Harry no longer impressionable or malleable by Voldy.
Is it your belief, then, Phil, that the link is *totally* closed at this point, because of the "unsplinching"? Or is the link still somehow open via the scar, but it won't be as strong or as useful to Voldy?
Siriusly Snapey Susan
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
More information about the the_old_crowd
archive