Were HP and DD wrong? (spoilers, of course)

[fhmaneely]

--- In the_old_crowd at yahoogroups.com, "bluesqueak" <pip at e...> wrote:
> Spoiler, spoiler, spoiler.
> And then we get more spoilers.
> Let's think about spoilers
> Let's write about spoilers
> But let no one see our spoilers.
> If they haven't finished the book.
> 
> Ginger wrote: 
> > If one has Horcruxes made, and is killed, does the part of the 
> soul 
> > in that person die? Or does one of the Horcruxes empty itself of 
a 
> > soul? In other words, when LV was killed at GH, did a part of his 
> > soul that was in him die or one that was in a Horcrux? In either 
> > case aren't we down to 6, unless he has made another to replace 
> the 
> > one he used then? 
> > 
> 
> Hmmm... maybe it was the part of the soul that was killed at GH 
went 
> into Harry?
> 
> Which raises another question about good old Snape. This hatred 
that 
> Harry always sees for himself in Snape - is it for Harry? Or does 
> Snape know or suspect that Harry contains part of Voldie's soul?
> 
> Is that what Snape is showing hatred to?
> 
> And that would explain why Snape is *so* hard on Harry, who cannot 
> understand why Snape is convinced that Harry's an egomaniac liar, 
> etc. If part of Voldemort's soul is in Harry, Harry is in terrible 
> danger of being taken over by it - and every time Snape sees 
> something that looks Voldemortish, he tries to squash it, 
ruthlessly.
> 
> The thing that approach *cannot* squash, of course, is hatred. 
Harry 
> hates really well. He hates Snape.
> 
> Or is it that the Voldemort within?
> 
> Pip!Squeak
> 
> "Where do you think would I have been all these years, if I had not 
> known how to act?" - Severus Snape

Harry could be a constant reminder of the terrible mistake he made. 
Also LV would have to commit the death before splitting his soul, 
right? Since he did not suceed, he could not have done the spell or 
whatever.
Fran