HBP: Dumbledore's hand
davewitley
dfrankiswork at davewitley.yahoo.invalid
Tue Jul 19 08:30:03 UTC 2005
I don't have my copy of HBP to verify this.
James has taken it to Devon to read on the train: his sister expressed
surprise that he was prepared to be seen to be uncool and his response
was that his colleague Dave always tries to be cool and 'he's really
into it - he was discussing it with Cathy'.
You have to laugh.
Debbie:
> I've also been mulling over the question of how to destroy a Horcrux,
> since Dumbledore pointedly doesn't tell us how he destroyed the ring
> and how he was hurt in the process.
My recollection is that Dumbledore turns up wearing the ring and with
an injured hand; later, the ring is gone.
So he got the injury *getting* the ring, not destroying it.
My recollection is also that Snape implied in "Spinner's End" that
Dumbledore was injured in a fight, rather than a magical accident.
I believe the story of how he came to be injured is a running joke.
JKR has made Dumbledore very secretive in order to concela important
plot points from us until she was ready to reveal them. She is
laughing at us, showing how she can still easily conceal things
despite the new, confiding, Dumbledore.
David
More information about the the_old_crowd
archive