HBP: Dumbledore's hand
eloise_herisson
eloiseherisson at eloise_herisson.yahoo.invalid
Tue Jul 19 09:41:43 UTC 2005
One original spoiler and I'm done!
One original spoiler and I'm done!
One original spoiler and I'm done!
One original spoiler and I'm done!
One original spoiler and I'm done!
One original spoiler and I'm done!
David:
> I don't have my copy of HBP to verify this.
Debbie:
> > I've also been mulling over the question of how to destroy a
Horcrux,
> > since Dumbledore pointedly doesn't tell us how he destroyed the
ring
> > and how he was hurt in the process.
David:
> My recollection is that Dumbledore turns up wearing the ring and
with
> an injured hand; later, the ring is gone.
>
> So he got the injury *getting* the ring, not destroying it.
Eloise:
I looked this up this morning after we discussed it last night (and I
inadvertently misled you).
Yes, he's wearing the ring, but it's already cracked. In its first
Pensieve appearance, there's no mention of such a crack, but a
mysterious allusion to the Peverell coat of arms:
"Know how much I've been offered for this, with the Peverell coat of
arms engraved on the stone?"
I cannot find a Peverell coat of arms that looks anything like
remotely Slytherinesque, so what that's about, I've no idea.
I think he must have made at least an abortive attempt to destroy it
before returning, injured, to Hogwarts for Snape's attentions *which
apparently probably saved his life* (if he were a traitor, why didn't
he just let him die? - sorry, had to put that in).
~Eloise
More information about the the_old_crowd
archive