Graveyard Horcrux?
pippin_999
foxmoth at pippin_999.yahoo.invalid
Mon Jul 25 14:08:14 UTC 2005
Double, double
Toil and trouble
Cauldron hiss and
Cauldron bubble
Eye of newt and wing of fleas
Nothing will clean these dungarees!
Heidi:
He couldn't have made one from Cedric as Wormtail did that killing.
And Wormtail was the reason I had a problem with the horcrux
concept, unfortunately. Wormtail killed a dozen people in one blow,
but even if it split his soul, did he do any horcruxing?
Pippin:
More evidence that Pettigrew is innocent. He's another Morphin,
IMO, no saint, but not a killer, either. His soul is torn with
treachery, and cowardice, not murder. So useful to have him
around. By now, I'm sure Voldie has him quite convinced that he did
murder all those people and kill Cedric, too. But canon is ambiguous.
Wormtail held the wand, quoth Jo, but who is "Wormtail" ? Peter only,
or Peter and someone else? More than one Prince, more than one Evans,
more than one Crouch, more than one Riddle. The clues accumulate.
Heidi:
Has Voldemort taught the trick to any death eaters, and is that
why they're so dangerous, because they kill other wizards to split
their own souls? Or has he held the information for himself?
Pippin:
I doubt very much that Voldemort would teach the trick to his
Death Eaters. No doubt he's promised them that he'll reveal the
secret of immortality once he's found it out, but in the graveyard
he makes it sound as if he doesn't know which of his
experiments saved his life, and as if he might be mortal once
more. Dumbledore confirms that the DE's don't know what he's
talking about when he says he's traveled further than anyone on
the road to immortality. I don't think Voldemort would want any
other immortal wizards competing with him.
Pippin
More information about the the_old_crowd
archive