checking out the library book / Love
pippin_999
foxmoth at pippin_999.yahoo.invalid
Sat Jun 18 14:27:15 UTC 2005
>
> Mike the Goat wrote in
> http://groups.yahoo.com/group/the_old_crowd/message/1819 :
>
> << Love as the greatest hidden force in the universe *is* a pretty
> standard idea. I think it has Judeo-Christian roots, >>
Rita:
> I'm not sure if it has Jewish roots. It DOES have roots in
> Christianity's other parent, Hellenism. Recall Plato's SYMPOSIUM.
>
Pippin:
The room that no one was allowed to enter has Jewish roots.
Inside the Holy of Holies, there was nothing, except when the
High Priest stood there once a year to confess and call
on the Name for pardon and blessing. The idea was that
God would do this because He loves His people.
A Jew might describe the force Harry is filled with as Yetzer
Hatov, the good inclination, of which love is only a part.
However, traditionally, the child under thirteen has only
Yetzer Hara, not the desire to do evil exactly, but the desire to
seek security, pleasure and property. The idea Dumbledore
seems to be hinting at, that the good inclination was
active in Harry at birth or could have been ensouled in him by
Lily's sacrifice, owes little to Judaism, IMO.
Pippin
More information about the the_old_crowd
archive