A few thoughts in passing
hg_skmg
hg_skmg at hg_skmg.yahoo.invalid
Sun Nov 6 02:57:51 UTC 2005
Ginger:
Anything JKR answers will be answered, and anything else is up to my
> imagination. I will be able to speculate with total abandon on
> anything she doesn't cover, which means I can go nuts in a way I
> haven't been able to since I finished PoA...When book 7 is
> done, I can do with JKR's world as I please, so long as it fits
canon.
hg:
Ginger, this is by far the most positive attitude I've read regarding
the end of the series, and I thank you for it. The thought never
once crossed my mind that our imaginings would be released from the
successive limitations (from the books, interviews, website), but
rather that it'd simply be all over. Perhaps the end won't be so
depressing after all.
Ginger:
> Another thought I had was about dragon's blood. Could it have
> healing powers? Hagrid used a dragon steak for his black eye in
OoP
> as one might use a beefsteak in real life. The twins wore dragon
> jackets rather than plain leather, explaining that they were
treating
> themselves as business was so good. It would seem that dragon is
> more expensive that cow, so why was Hagrid using the more expensive
> cut of meat? Healing powers? Was that Dragon's blood trickling
from
> DD's mouth? If so, what did he intend by it?
hg:
Now you've got my mind racing. First off, I've been confused for
quite some time about the different colors of dragon's blood we see:
The steak is dripping greenish blood, but the blood on the walls in
the Muggle house Slughorn is inhabiting is glutinous and red. Are
they both dragon's blood? I've read elsewhere speculation that
Hagrid had Common Welsh Green meat on his face -- could the
difference of breed allow a difference in color? I also thought
maybe the blood dripping down Hagrid's face perhaps had a green
iridescence, like a tuna steak. (Sheesh, what revolting images.) Of
course, it's not nearly as fun to come up with either such reasonable
explanation; I'd rather suppose that Slughorn was full of it and it
wasn't dragon's blood at all, and for some reason Dumbledore didn't
call him on it.
But nonetheless, there's Hagrid nursing his wounds with dragon meat.
Perhaps one of the uses of dragon's blood is indeed for healing
purposes. You bring up the jackets -- the twins, soon after being
seen wearing them, are developing Shield Cloaks -- I wonder if
there's any connection.
Then, finally, I have long thought the blood on Dumbledore's mouth
was the same dusty blood Slughorn rebottled in chapter 4. Surely
there's a better reason for this action than to demonstrate his
thriftiness.
Ginger:
> What I think would be cool (which means that she probably will come
> up with something cooler) would be for Harry to get notes via owl
> with messages like "Go to Godric's Hollow and look at the base of
the
> elm tree in the back yard. Sincerely, your friend who likes
> raspberry jam." We'd be wondering all book long if DD is still
> alive, or if it was someone like Snape (if he's good) using the jam
> as a password. Either it could be DD, who faked his death, finally
> having time to go hunt the horcruces unhindered, or it could be
> Snape, who has found out about them by Legilimancing LV and is
> passing on the info, or something else I haven't thought of yet.
hg:
Love this idea. There, too, was something that aggravatingly didn't
return in HBP, the jam password. This train of thought interests me
because it's a clean way of structuring Harry's journey. Might I add
that if he did indeed fake it, perhaps he thought he gave Harry
enough info to find the ones he knew about, leaving him free to wait
for Voldemort to unwittingly direct him to the unknown Horcrux, which
I think is almost certainly at Hogwarts.
hg.
More information about the the_old_crowd
archive