Give a dog a bad name
Barry Arrowsmith
arrowsmithbt at kneasy.yahoo.invalid
Wed Jan 4 13:34:18 UTC 2006
Some firm views being expressed re: Lupin at the moment.
These and a name mentioned in an off-site mail from Rebecca garnering
opinions on certain aspects of Draco (yep; I'll give it some skull
time, promise - but just now I'm flitting about like a leaden
butterfly) brings me back to a line that I've ranted about previously.
Names.
IMO the only excitement likely to be forthcoming about Remus is who
he really is.
It's too fantastic that his parents would give him a name so
apposite, so fitting, for someone who years later would contract a
specific incurable disease.
I've muttered into my beard before that it must be his nom de chien,
assumed when his medical condition (and pariah status) became
evident. Otherwise it'd be the equivalent of a RL individual being
named Bitz Dropoff and later contracting leprosy.
Then there was Rebecca's mail - in which she mentioned Fenrir Greyback.
Bugger me! Another one!
One is bad enough - but two!?!
Another werewolf, both of whose names have wolfish associations.
Now come on. Are we expected to swallow the idea that werewolves are
preferentially attracted to those with lupine cognomens? Do they flip
through the WW population census searching for suitable victims?
"Felix Scratch, no... he's due for feline leukaemia; Bodley Harm,
no... he's gonna get Crucio-ed; ah! here's one! Cubby Loup! Yes, he's
gonna be one of ours. Next full moon."
Or are their respective parents gifted with prophetic foresight and
thus able to make appropriate arrangements when naming their to-be-
afflicted-sometime-in-the-future offspring?
It's generally accepted that Jo takes a great deal of care in
choosing names. What about in the two werewolf characters? Has she
indulged in a little premature nomenclature? Foisting ludicrously
prophetic and descriptive names onto cast members? Or is it something
we should take note of?
Here's an outside possibility - when entered into the Werewolf
Register, werewolves are given new, descriptive names that give fair
warning to all contacts of just what they're dealing with. A
werewolf. It's that or lock 'em up for the protection of the public.
Protects the family name, too.
Sound feasible?
If that is the case - just who is/was Lupin?
Kneasy
More information about the the_old_crowd
archive