Flying in WAS Some questions
bluesqueak
pip at bluesqueak.yahoo.invalid
Sun Jan 15 23:47:16 UTC 2006
Snow wrote:
>
> (2) If the castle is protected from anyone flying into the grounds
> (via Dumbledore and Harry flying into Hogwarts for the final
showdown
> on the tower), how did the Ford Anglia manage to get through the
> magical defenses in COS?
>
Pip!Squeak:
One very simple solution is that Dumbledore added to the defenses
when Hogwarts started to develop that safe, tranquil air most noted
in the East End of London during the height of the Blitz {g}.
So in Books 1 and 2 there might be no defenses against brooms.
People can fly in. Why not? It's a normal mode of wizarding
transport, much more visible than apparition. Allowing apparition
would mean a thief could go straight to DD's office, say, and nick
all the valuables. But you can see someone coming in on a
broomstick. Really, it's the equivalent of someone driving a car in -
why should they think to stop it in normal times? There's probably
some standing request to check in at the office and not fly over the
quidditch pitch in case you crash into a student, and that's it.
But sometime during Books 3 to 6 Hogwarts is made a no-fly-zone - no
crossing the walls on a broomstick. Sometime during these books
(maybe after the QWC episode, or maybe during PoA) Dumbledore has
protected the castle against aerial entry.
Changing the spells during PoA makes most sense; blocking flying
means there's no way into the castle except the entryways Dumbledore
knows about.
Pip!Squeak
"Where do you think I would have been all these years, if I had not
known how to act?" - Severus Snape
More information about the the_old_crowd
archive