Only TWO Die? No, wait...
bluesqueak
pip at bluesqueak.yahoo.invalid
Thu Jun 29 20:03:36 UTC 2006
Anne wrote:
>
> I just reread Firenze's first Divination lesson in OoP this
> morning, where he told the class, "In the past decade, the
> indications have been that Wizard-kind is living through nothing
> more than a brief calm between two wars."
>
> I don't think we can call what we've had so far a "war." Not even
> a little one.
No,it's a war. It's just that our particular heroes are (until the
last few chapters) largely on the edges of it - the equivalent of
schoolkids who'd been evacuated to a safe place in the country, and
are only seeing the war by the effects on people whose relatives get
killed. Kids vanish from the school because a parent, or brother, or
sister has died. Ron gets hit by the equivalent of shrapnel from an
attack meant on someone else. People are being arrested 'on
suspicion'. There are attacks on the Order of the Phoenix, all the
Weasley's are in 'mortal peril', the story starts with a bridge
being destroyed resulting in people's deaths, it ends with a
successful enemy invasion of the supposedly safe Hogwarts.
What we're in, in Book Six, is the moment before our heroes are old
enough to legally say 'stuff school, we're joining in the fight full
time.' Using a Second World War analogy, it's the moment when
they're in the Air Cadets and are being used for some of the less
dangerous tasks, but aren't yet old enough to join the Royal Air
Force. So there is *a* war - but the Trio themselves aren't yet *at*
war.
Anne:
>Seems like we ought to be in for a lot of mayhem in the
> next twelve months while Harry is busy collecting Horcruxes.
I'd agree with that. The difference between on sidelines with bombs
droppin and being in a full-scale battle.
Pip!Squeak
More information about the the_old_crowd
archive