Who's a Warlock vs a Wizard in HP?

quigonginger quigonginger at quigonginger.yahoo.invalid
Thu Mar 2 12:58:03 UTC 2006


Rebecca wrote:
(snip)
> Since DD was Chief *Warlock* of the Wizengamot, I assume that the Old 
> English etymology of "deceiver" or "oathbreaker" isn't appropriate 
here, but 
> is the other speculated Anglo Saxon interpretation "the man of the 
logs" 
> (referring to the reading of runes) correct? Or even just "male 
witch", as I 
> have seen some definitions say?  (snip)

Ginger, who has no answer, but wants to pipe up anyway:

This has been asked quite a few times on TOL.  For those of you who 
still hold membership there, you may be interested in the following 
posts:  18800, 30325, 30327, 35330, 37741, 37749, 41799, 41800, 41805, 
41816, 41830, and 41831.

I just got done reviewing this category for the catalogue project, and 
these posts cover the ideas that had been bandied about up to the 
release of OoP.  

As for my personal opinion:  I think it is about the same as the 
difference between lad and boy.  I don't have a clue, but it's there.  
Somehow or other, you just know which one to say at which time.  Or at 
least, JKR does.

Take your pick.  With any luck, some of the authors of those posts (who 
haven't changed their minds) will speak up.

Cheers, Ginger, who is definately a chick. 








More information about the the_old_crowd archive