Who knew that Peter was the Secret Keeper? (Was: After all this time...)
Neri
nkafkafi at nkafkafi.yahoo.invalid
Thu Mar 2 15:27:27 UTC 2006
> Talisman:
> Since the topic has re-emerged, I'll answer Neri's objection re: If
> the secret dies with the keeper, why wouldn't LV just make people
> his Hx SKs, and then kill them, thus insuring no one could ever find
> the blasted things again:
>
> Because you never know who's going to come back as a ghost, that's
> why.
> <snip>
>
> I imagine LV expects most people to fear death, as he does. That
> being the case, he'd expect almost anyone to leave a ghost behind.
>
Neri:
In such case, one wonders why did Voldy kill Bertha in GoF? She could
come back as a ghost and foil his plan. But maybe he made sure her
memory was completely destroyed before he killed her? Hmm, a good
point. Must remember to obliviate the Hx SKs before you kill'em.
>
> Once you've shot your wad, SK-wise, it's out of your hands. You
> can't decide to make another SK for the same secret, because you can
> no longer ever tell anyone, yourself.
>
Neri:
Not exactly. If the secret is the house where the Hx was hidden, and
you have a reason to suspect that the SK (dead or not) had blabbered,
you just take the Hx out of this house and hide it somewhere else,
using another SK.
Neri
More information about the the_old_crowd
archive