[the_old_crowd] Re:Collateral Damage, Gryffindor Horcrux, sunken ships and logical ravens

[ewe2]

On 7/24/07, Kirstini <kirst_inn at ...> wrote:
>  I spoil you spoil he/she/it spoils they have spoiled we will all be spoiled  I spoil you spoil
> he/she/it spoils they have spoiled we will all be spoiled  I spoil you spoil he/she/it spoils
> they have spoiled we will all be spoiled  I spoil you spoil he/she/it spoils they have spoiled
> we will all be spoiled  I spoil you spoil he/she/it spoils they have spoiled we will all be
> spoiled  I spoil you spoil he/she/it spoils they have spoiled we will all be spoiled  I spoil
> you spoil he/she/it spoils they have spoiled we will all be spoiled, and I must not tell lies,
> either.


> Do you know the main problem I had with the book? It was that link Kneasy sent us last
> week to the Logical Raven fanfic (yes, I've been lurking creepily about for a while). I
> thought it was pretty poorly written, to be honest. Lost patience after a few chapters of
> constant location jumping, with nothing much being done.
> I realised last night I've actually been confusing events in the fanfic with the actual book.
>
> Kirstini, a bit dejected.
>

It wasn't just you. I was ticking off the successful predictions as I
went along, remarking upon the spooky harmony of canon and imitation.

A question for the ages: What now to make of the missing hours on the
day the Boy Who Lived, lived? Is it worth revisiting in the light of
Final Canon, or it is now just useless pottering about (ow, i didn't
mean that pun, stop hitting me)?

ewe2

-- 
Emacs vs. Vi flamewars are a pointless waste of time. Vi is the best