The extra scene

katzefan katzefan at yahoo.com
Sun Apr 21 06:33:05 UTC 2002


--- In HPFGU-Movie at y..., "alhewison" <Ali at z...> wrote:
....In the film though, Lily hasn't even taken Harry out 
> of his cot yet. Arguably, she could have been at the opposite 
end of  the house to Harry, and had just run to get him. I got the 
feeling though that she hadn't tried to get him and make a run for 
it. Maybe  she didn't think she could get out of the door, but you'd 
think that she'd still pick Harry up to protect him. ?
> 
> Any thoughts on this?
> 
> Ali

I thought, during the flashback scene in the movie, she *was* 
holding Harry as Voldemort approached the room (I got the 
impression it was Harry's room). 
I seem to recall her holding the baby quite tightly, and I think I 
recall green light starting to seep in around the door, although 
I'm not absolutely sure of that.
However, a later scene (by which time I assume Lily and James 
are dead) shows a wand pointing squarely at the baby, who's 
sitting on what appears to be a chesterfield, or something 
similar, and I confess I'm wondering how he got from Lily's arms 
to there. If Voldemort was out to kill the whole family, he'd hardly 
have been considerate enough to catch Harry as his mother fell 
and then prop him up carefully before performing the Avada 
Kedavra curse....





More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive