The extra scene

[alhewison]

--- In HPFGU-Movie at y..., "katzefan" <katzefan at y...> wrote:
> 
> I thought, during the flashback scene in the movie, she *was* 
> holding Harry as Voldemort approached the room (I got the 
> impression it was Harry's room). 
> I seem to recall her holding the baby quite tightly, and I think I 
> recall green light starting to seep in around the door, although 
> I'm not absolutely sure of that.
> However, a later scene (by which time I assume Lily and James 
> are dead) shows a wand pointing squarely at the baby, who's 
> sitting on what appears to be a chesterfield, or something 
> similar, and I confess I'm wondering how he got from Lily's arms 
> to there. If Voldemort was out to kill the whole family, he'd 
hardly 
> have been considerate enough to catch Harry as his mother fell 
> and then prop him up carefully before performing the Avada 
> Kedavra curse....

Oh woops! Now you've said that I can remember that clear as a bell!. 
I do worry about my memory sometimes though. I did see the film 3 
times too!

I do wonder though why Lily hadn't tried to run. If she knew that 
Voldemort had come to her house, surely she knew she was tempting 
fate to stay? Shuting the door was hardly going to keep him out, so 
why didn't she try and make a run for it? - Unless she didn't feel 
she (or Harry) were at risk?


Ali

(who feels very stupid that her memory is so bad, and is looking 
forward to the DVD coming out on the 11th!)