Nebula awards prelim ballot posted

lupinesque aiz24 at hotmail.com
Fri Jan 25 02:12:45 UTC 2002


Andrew wrote:

> There having been discussion w.r.t. the Hugo awards,
> the pro version (Nebula awards) prelim ballot has been
> posted to:
> 
> http://www.sfwa.org/News/nebpre01.htm
> 
> Interesting to note that Pullman made it for _The
> Amber Spyglass_ but Rowling didn't for any of hers.

Looking on this website, I see the Nebula comes from the Science 
Fiction **and Fantasy** Writers of America.

I thought part of the controversy about the Hugo was that it was 
purely for scifi (which one would have to construe pretty broadly to 
encompass HP)?  It would be ironic if GF won an award for which it 
really should have been ineligible and now doesn't even get nominated 
for the genre to which it undoubtedly belongs.

Amy
who, forced to take only one or the other to that mythical desert 
island, would take The Amber Spyglass 

. . . but please don't make me choose!





More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter archive