Good story/bad writer: (Was: What a snob!)/SPOILER for Twilight and Dawn

[zanooda2]

--- In HPFGU-OTChatter at yahoogroups.com, "dumbledore11214" <dumbledore11214 at ...> wrote:


S

P

O

I

L

E

R




> I meant that all vampires to me are monsters by default, 
> definitely some of them do not want to be monsters and 
> exorcise monsters out, but to me it is still there.


zanooda:

I don't know, to me Bella\Edward situation was a little creepy mostly because those vampires are *too* different, like some alien species, not because they are monsters in a moral way. They fight against their nature, trying not to be monsters, and I respect that :-). 


> Alla:

> Of course they do not want to kill humans and Carlisle did 
> not even, but even Edward did, right during his eh retreat, 
> unless I am misremembering (before books started I mean, 
> what he tells Bella).


zanooda:

No, you remember right (I just read it last month, so I didn't forget it yet :-)). That was a "vigilante" stage of his life (or existence, more like), LOL.


> Alla:

> Like werewolves are monsters for me, and I do not consider 
> Jacob or Remus  Lupin to be one.


Jacob is not a real werewolf, like Lupin. He is a shape-shifter, like Sirius Black (Animagus, LOL). He transforms at will and he keeps his human mind... 


zanooda, noticing that this thread took somehow a Halloween-ish turn... vampires, werewolves, monsters... boo :-)!