Good story/bad writer: (Was: What a snob!)/SPOILER for Twilight and Dawn

[dumbledore11214]

zanooda:

I don't know, to me Bella\Edward situation was a little creepy mostly because
those vampires are *too* different, like some alien species, not because they
are monsters in a moral way. They fight against their nature, trying not to be
monsters, and I respect that :-).


Alla:

Oh sure they were different, lol, they were different to such degree that I at some point wondered if we could truly call  them vampires, since while I do not mind author making folklore creatures to be their own, this was a bit over the top IMO. However, again since they had an urge to drink blood, I still think of them as vampires. And yes, many vampires I like do fight against their nature in one way or another. Angel will always be my favorite example of course.

But these ones, they are  special of course, sparkling ones! 

Alla:

> Like werewolves are monsters for me, and I do not consider
> Jacob or Remus Lupin to be one.

Zanooda:
Jacob is not a real werewolf, like Lupin. He is a shape-shifter, like Sirius
Black (Animagus, LOL). He transforms at will and he keeps his human mind...


Alla:

Yeah, he is Meyer!werewolf lol, same as Remus is JKR!werewolf. 


zanooda, noticing that this thread took somehow a Halloween-ish turn...
vampires, werewolves, monsters... boo :-)!

Alla:

Let's make it real scary.

BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO. Scared yet? ;)