Sorting Dean Thomas

Simon Biber simon at basilisk2.cjb.net
Fri Dec 15 06:32:45 UTC 2000


No: HPFGUIDX 6965

So now both editions are wrong :-(

Actually to me Dean Thomas wasn't a major character, perhaps he was in a
different year. Unless it states otherwise.

Simon.

> I understand from previous discussion on this list that there is a
> difference between the US and UK editions in that scene. Someone
> posted it as "an error in the US edition": the text says now there
> were only THREE more students to be Sorted, Thomas, Dean, then
> Turpin, Lisa, then Weasley, Ronald, then Zabini, Blaise -- which is
> FOUR. But if Dean Thomas was not Sorted at all, that would be an
> error in the UK edition.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive