Who will Die (Was Re: Harry As Survivor)

mollypickle at hotmail.com mollypickle at hotmail.com
Tue Dec 4 03:38:13 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 30706


  I agree with you in that Harry is "The Boy Who Lived." He's going 
to make it through all. All seven books. No matter what, he makes it 
through. He may be injured, he may be maimed, taken hostage, 
tortured, but he lives. 

  HOWEVER.... I beg to differ with you about Ron and Hermione. I 
don't know which one (or both) will be taken, but I'm certain that 
one will meet with a highly tragic end inspiring some very heroic 
action on Potter's part leading up to the climax of the entire 
series. I'm leaning toward saying Hermoine, since she is the female, 
but then again, she's always proved herself so smart and resourceful 
in the past, she's not one to play the "damsel in distress."  It 
could be both Ron and Hermoine, who, involved in a romantic 
relationship, die a similar death to the Potters, defending each 
other. 

   I just have a feeling that not all three are going to make it 
through... and since Harry HAS to make it through... Ron and Hermione 
are the two left....

   -Molly Denton

******************************
Trading stickers your thing? 
Come to Sticker Swappin' Station
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/stickerswappinstation
*******************************




> --- In HPforGrownups at y..., ladjables at y... wrote:
> > Hello,
> > I'm new, so I don't know if this has been discussed to death but 
I 
> > would just like to offer some thoughts on who will die 
[shudder].  
> I 
> > have read some previous posts and while I agree that most of the 
> > characters, my beloved Lupin, Sirius and Hargid among others will 
> > die, I've always felt certain that Harry will definitely live.  I 
> > want to say Harry, Ron and Hermione but I don't want to push it.
> > 
> > And my reason for saying Harry will survive is simply this: that 
is 
> > who Harry is.  Not just a great Seeker, or possibly an all-
powerful 
> > wizard, but someone who always endures; he is essentially the Boy 
> Who 
> > Lived.  He has escaped Voldemort on numerous occasions, but he 
has 
> > also toughed it out at the Dursleys and deals with betrayal and 
> > ostracism very well.  My boy will survive.  At what cost I know 
> not.  
> > Any thoughts?  Could someone convince me that L, S and H will not 
> die?
> > Ladja





More information about the HPforGrownups archive