SHIP: The Project

davewitley dfrankiswork at netscape.net
Wed Dec 12 00:49:52 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 31332

Penny:

> When the shippers have parsed & argued their way through all 
available 
> evidence about Hermione's feelings, it has become evident to all 
> involved that there's no clear answer.  There is arguable evidence 
that 
> she does return Ron's budding interest.  There is also *just as 
much* 
> arguable evidence that she has interest in Harry.  Most shippers 
choose 
> to accent the evidence that favors their preference.

Hegel would spin in his grave, if he wasn't busy cracking jokes with 
the Fat Friar.  This is a ceasefire, not a resolution.  What we need 
to do now is pull together Gwen's and others' thoughts on how we 
develop an understanding that is *uniquely* consistent with canon, 
and use the resulting methodology to pull the synthesis out of the 
thesis and antithesis.  What happened to that vaunted American know-
how and can-do spirit?

We don't have long before OOP, so we'd better get cracking.  Who's 
game?

David, finally at the end of this evening's burst of creativity, or 
is that confusion?





More information about the HPforGrownups archive