Harry's eyes and scar (seer??), Lily adopted
Indigo
indigo at indigosky.net
Sat Jul 28 16:14:05 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 23128
--- In HPforGrownups at y..., meboriqua at a... wrote:
> Both of the dreams that I mentioned are vague, but Seeing is not a
> precise art. I think JKR makes that point clear. Someone
mentioned
> "The Mists of Avalon" as an example, saying that the women who
could
> See didn't have complete control over their Seeing and could not
See
> everything all the time. Any book, movie or tv show I have seen
that
> deals with Seeing shows it to be hard to control and often left
open
> for interpretation. Even Trelawney (who I think is a big phony
> anyway) does not know when she really Sees. Harry is still quite
> young and is learning to control his magical abilities and his
> emotions. Recognizing the possibility of being a Seer is beyond
him
> at this point.
>
Ah!
Now *this* makes sense.
My fear was that if Lily was a Seer she was like the best Seer, who
made Trelawney look sick [not terribly difficult, but I was thinking
extreme contrast].
This makes sense.
I think Harry just believes what Dumbledore tells him -- that his
scar connects him to Voldemort, so his dreams occasionally give him
clues.
next year, though, I have a guess he'll be beginning to see things on
his own. He's always been somewhat perceptive but he'll be 15.
That's when a lot of kids begin to come into their own [and Harry's
got a head start on that magically, but not as a person entirely].
Thanks for straightening me out!
Indigo
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive