[HPforGrownups] Re: Cross-book Foreshadowing (WAS Snape and Harry's first meeting)

Tue Nov 13 04:21:23 UTC 2001

No: HPFGUIDX 29156

Hello David,

>  an explanation of cross-book second time foreshadowing
> (CBSTF) and the search for examples.

Might the fact that Ron's spell on Scabbers ("turn this fat rat
yellow") did not work have been because he was not a rat? We are led
to believe that the spell is a dud, but could it be that a spell for a
rat does not work on an animargus? Just a thought....