How will Battle commence?
pippin_999
foxmoth at qnet.com
Fri Apr 26 22:11:00 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 38226
The Grey Wolf wrote:
>
> Non-possibility A:
> What I really don't believe it will happen is an all-out war. There
> just isn't enough people to form an army, and a wizard war
would be too destructive and alarm-raising. Even Voldemort
knows they cannot reveal themselves to muggles, they'd be
swarmed over with little or no difficulty (we muggles have guns.
Better than AK, anytime). Except if some other listee comes with
some idea to support the army war, I think it will be a terrorism
war in any of it's multiple forms, with no actual face-to-face
confrontations except at a very small scale.<<<<
As I understand things, terrorist insurgencies aim to radicalize
the populace. They want to provoke those in power to take
drastic action, which will inevitably harm innocent people, who
will then join the terrorist cause. Terrorists are nihilists: they may
dream of victory but they don't really care, they just want to bring
the violence home, to quote a slogan from the radicals of my
youth.
Voldemort got the Ministry to authorize the use of The
Unforgiveables. If things had gone on, I'm sure there would have
been pressure on the Ministry to use the Dark Arts as well. We
may see this in the remaining books. As far as revealing the
wizarding world to Muggles, I think that is exactly what Voldemort
wants. He certainly doesn't seem at all concerned about
maintaining wizarding secrecy. IMO, his aim is all-out
Muggle/Wizard war, with the hope of exterminating or enslaving
every Muggle on earth. Thus his quest for immortality, so that
wizards can survive without relying on Muggle mates.
Victory may be beyond his grasp but it may not look that way to
him. I have a feeling guns wouldn't be much use against
Dementors. Muggles can't see them, but are affected by them.
And how many bullets does it take to kill an armored giant? Can
a Parselmouth control dragons? They would be devastating
weapons. Dumbledore and co. will certainly try to prevent things
from getting that far, but will they succeed, or will the ultimate
victory of the Light Side entail massive memory charms?
If Voldemort can persuade the Dementors to join him then he
will have a ready-made fortress/headquarters at Azkaban from
which to launch his attacks, invisible to Muggles and guarded
from Wizards as well. How he is to be dislodged from it and
vanquished I have no idea, though I am pretty sure that Godric's
sword is going to come in handy.
>
> Grey Wolf, a bit peeved at the fact that only he seems to be
waiting until Monday to discuss elf rigths.
I'm waiting, I'm waiting !
Pippin
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive