Book 5 Predictions - Well someone had to do it.

Hollydaze hollydaze at btinternet.com
Fri Feb 15 20:33:29 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 35289

Sorry if we can't reply to these but I presume we can!
Felicia Rickmann wrote:
> PREDICTION - ONE
> * Deep Breath *  Remus Lupin is for the high jump/chop/is a marked 
> man/on the way out i.e. will die. (This breaks my heart, I LOVE the 
> man and HOPE I'm wrong).  I did think of Dumbledore but could not 
> bring myself to associate his name with death (yet).
> 
> JUSTIFICATION 
> Someone has to die - it can't be Sirius.  Anyone, Anyone but 
> Severus... (OK so I'm stuck on him too....)

Ok well, according to a couple of websites I regularly look at, JK has stated in an couple of interviews that Lupin has a big role to play in book 7 so I'm not so sure about this one! He can't exactly play a big role if he's dead (unless he becomes a ghost?)


> PREDICTION - TWO
> They get to travel.
> 
> JUSTIFICATION
> We all need a change of scenery (too many underground tunnels & 
> visits to Hogsmead can lose their allure).  Boot camp at Durmstrang 
> or Ron re-visiting his passion for Fleur Delacour at Beauxbatons, 
> Rumania, Little Gidding, Egypt???

I like that idea, although maybe not to those places, JK ahs stated we get to visit a new "world" a totally magical one, maybe they get to travel there, although if it is only for one chapter (like the diary or the Pensieve) that would be a little disappointing. Mind I can't see a "totally new world" being a memory as that kinda contradicts itself doesn't it?

> PREDICTION - THREE
> Harry will fall in love with Cho with the field now clear of Cedric 
> Diggory, her former inamorata.   Either that or get a crush on his 
> Defence Against the Dark Arts teacher - strongly rumoured to be 
> female in OotP.
> 
> JUSTIFICATION
> He's at THAT STAGE in his life - * Girls * have already made 
> appearances in that direction (GoF) OotP just takes it further.  
> Let's just hope Ron's interpersonal skills improve in this area too!  I have to say I agree with the people who say that Harry won't go any where near Cho now because of the guilt he feels about how Cedric died. I don't think Cho is the sort of person who would accuse him or anything, far from it, I think she would be very understanding. I just think that harry will think she holds it against him, or that he will hold it against himself.

> PREDICTION - FOUR
> Mrs Dursley - in denial for most of her life - will be outed as The 
> Other Witch in the family. 
> 
> JUSTIFICATION
> None.  The idea is just too wild for words!!!!  I just want to see 
> how JKR handles it, if its true.   
Umm well there is actually, JK has stated that someone will perform magic in "dire circumstances" in a future book, someone who ahs never performed magic before. now the only people I can think it would refer to are Filch or the Dursleys. I don't really think it would have much meaning to us if it was Filch while it would be plain hilarious if one of the Dursleys did something considering how much they hate wizard folk (especially if it was Dudley their own son!!)


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]





More information about the HPforGrownups archive