TBAY: Minerva McGonagall Is Ever So Evil! Not

[jtdogberry]

No: HPFGUIDX 39886


> Mysteryreefer:
> 
> > OK, I read all the posts regarding Evil Minerva and I have 2 
> > questions-- if she is indeed so powerful, why couldn't she 
> > conjure up a patronus to ward off the dementor from Barty Jr.? 
> > However, if she is just a plant for Voldemort, why did she try to 
> > hard to get Hermione a Time Turner in PoA? Unless that was 
> > actually Dumbledore's idea.... 


It could be that it happened too fast for her to stop. She had to 
stay with Crouch Jnr, if Fudge came in, she may not have seen the 
dementor in time. Remember that Snape saw it as well. 
Also, Lupin said that many grown wizards have trouble with the charm, 
Mcgonagall said so herself, that she is not the best at charms in POA 
when she said that she would take the Firebolt to Flitwick.

The time turner, she really believes that Herminone is a brilliant 
student, she gave her a rare smile on the first lesson. She would 
have had to speak with Dumbledore first.

I really don't believe that she is evil at all.

Dogberry